What is piecemeal reform

Please note that corrections may take a couple of weeks to filter through the various RePEc services. Economic literature: papers , articles , software , chapters , books.

FRED data. My bibliography Save this book chapter. Piecemeal reform: Is it the answer? The chapter considers the question of how best to reform a fully developed law of secured transactions. A system may have functioned reasonably well over a number of years, but through changing usage, judicial decisions and policy-driven statutory modification may have grown over-complex, contain inconsistencies and become inefficient.

Style: MLA. English Language Learners Definition of piecemeal. Kids Definition of piecemeal. Get Word of the Day daily email! Test Your Vocabulary. Test your vocabulary with our question quiz! Love words? Need even more definitions? Homophones, Homographs, and Homonyms The same, but different. Credit: UK House of Lords , parliamentary copyright.

But what, exactly, is the basis for these claims? The first potential source of constitutional crisis would be that the Lords have acted against the Parliament Act , which states :. The tax credit legislation was not so certified by the Speaker.

It was, in fact, a piece of Secondary Legislation. The Parliament Act has not been breeched. The second potential Constitutional issue is in relation to parliamentary convention and the Salisbury Doctrine which. Very well, but the proposed changes to tax credits were not in the Conservative Manifesto. Nowhere in the Conservative manifesto is there any mention of the sort of changes to tax credits envisioned in the proposed legislation.

In light of this, it is difficult to maintain that the convention of the Salisbury Doctrine has been broken. In any case, as Vernon Bogdanor pointed out in The New British Constitution , the Salisbury Doctrine arose in an era in which there was a permanent inbuilt Tory majority in the Upper House — a state of affairs which ended with the House of Lords Act and the reduction of the number of hereditary peers to Whether or not the Salisbury Doctrine needs to apply in full now that no party has an automatic majority in the Lords has been question, and certainly the Lords have become more assertive since the reforms.

Mr Cameron finds himself in the new situation for a Conservative Prime Minister of not having a majority in the Lords — and he clearly does not like it. He would, no doubt, like to enjoy the full fruits of being PM in a centralised UK with the full sovereignty of parliament meaning in this case the House of Commons at his disposal, but is being thwarted.

Once again the Constitution seems vulnerable to piecemeal reform arising out of sectional party interest. Please read our comments policy before posting. He is the author of Official Irish Republicanism, to During he was an administrative assistant at No. He has a PhD on the history of special advisers in British government. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Email Address. WordPress Theme by Solostream. Should the UK lower the voting age to 16? Lords reform: the problem of piecemeal constitutional amendment. Posted in: Elections and electoral systems , Parliament.

Subscribe If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to receive more just like it. Comments are closed. Democratic Dashboard. Subscribe to Blog via Email Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. My Tweets.